Today I am going to review Robert
Jackson Bennett's book, City of Blades. This is the second
installment in an urban fantasy trilogy titled, The Divine
Cities. After a lengthy consideration, I decided to write this
review in a very different way. I hope my thoughts will interest you. I am going to start my review this way...
Some say, life has no meaning if there
is no afterlife.
I question, can afterlife have meaning
without afterafterlife?
Ok, let me set aside the (half) joke.
Lying at the core of most
religious/spiritual beliefs, is the notion, there is a heavenly
existence beyond the current one. By following a particular god, so
say the evangelists, one can be granted with salvation, and receiving
the key to enter some sort of “heaven”. While different religions
phrase the mechanics for salvation differently, but the general idea
remains the same. Therefore, let's just stick to this concept for
what it is– you follow some god, and that god will give you
salvation, and brings you to some kind of heaven when your earthly existence is due.
I suppose, people can incessantly argue
about the existence of heaven, hell, salvation, sin, and the whole
shebang. But I am interested in a different question:
Will you still follow your god, if
your god does not promise an afterlife and reward in heaven? If
your god says, you only have this single life, when it is due and the
universe dies, then it is game over and you cease to exist, no more.
Will you still follow your god?
“But there must be heaven for the
faithful and hell for the rebellious”, you said, “otherwise there
is no judgement for the moral right and wrong." With a stern face, you concluded, "a god who does not reward or punish, is
no god at all”.
“What do you mean, right and wrong?”,
I said, “currently, your god sounds awfully like a deity who was
created in your image, to fulfill your fancy for how the universe ought
to behave”.
“In fact”, I continued, “Is a thing good because your god says it is good? Or does your god say a thing is good because it is good? If you respond with the later,
then it means “good” comes from a higher source, and it imposes itself on your god, making your god redundant for moral good.
On the other hand, if you respond with the former, then you are
subscribing to a harmful belief, where whatever your god commands to
be good, is good (religious terrorism, anyone?).
“Ok listen”, you said, “there is
a third option, the nature of my god is good, so my god cannot
command anything that is against his nature”.
“Hmm”, I questioned, “where did
the nature of your god come from?”. A small pause, then I
continued, “If you say, your god is the uncreated creator, and is
therefore in control, or self-creating, of his nature, then it means
good is once again, based on your god's authority, and we are back to
the harmful belief, where you believe whatever your god commands is
good, is good. Alternatively, if your god does not choose that
nature, then the source that imposed the nature upon your god, is the
source of good and your god is once again, made redundant for moral
good.”
What a dilemma! Please excuse me if the
above paragraphs are dense and heady. I hope it is interesting.
However, you are welcomed to try and resolve this problem. But this
dilemma, known as Euthyphro dilemma, first proposed by Socrates, has
remained unsolved for thousands of years. This is the silver bullet
to those who use the moral argument for the existence of supernatural
deities.
My gentle readers, while I leave you to
explore this dilemma, my question remains: Will you still follow your
god if he does not promise you an afterlife, or reward in heaven?
City of Blades explores the
above question.
Like many good novels, this book started with a mystery. A secret agent has gone missing on the cold,
windy shore of Voortyashtan. This is a domain once belonged to the
(now) deceased goddess of war and destruction. Since the goddess'
demise, the city of Voortyashtan has lost much of its former glory,
it is reduced to an outpost, troubled by savage tribes. General
Turyuin Mulaghesh received a call from the prime minister of Saypuri.
Reluctantly, Mulaghesh left her retired life, and agreed to
investigate the fate of the missing agent. As Mulaghesh came closer
to the heart of the mystery, so does the dead whisper louder in her
ears. She wonders, after a god died, what happens to the souls of the
dead who are trapped in the afterlife?
City of Blades stands apart from
a galore of books in the genre. The worldbuilding in this book evokes
the image of post-colonialism. Furthermore, its characterization is
unlike most fantasy novels, it does not feature a young and dashing
hero. Instead, Mulaghesh, the protagonist, is a 50 something year old
woman. She is an ex-military, a weathered creature, who became
handicapped during her service. This also means Mulaghesh walks
around carrying some baggage from the past; a few regrets, a few
horrid memories from wars, and she has tasted the bitter and the
sweet in life. Mulaghesh is far from being the all-powerful and
flawless hero of fantasy archetype. She is experienced and a bit
cynical. Yet, under her hard exterior lies a tired soul who genuinely
tries to do the right thing. I like Mulaghsesh, while there are many
interesting supporting characters in this book, but she carries the
narratives on her own.
City of Blades, like its predecessor,
is a fusion of fantasy, mystery, and spy novels. It explores the
question about afterlife, and its role in the relationship between
believers and their god. It does so, through a story about gods,
miracles, the death of gods, and the death of miracles. The theme is
thought-provoking, and not wholly unrelated to the philosophies I
attempted to expound in my opening paragraphs. The book is very
well-written, its story is interesting, featuring a cast of memorable
characters. I do have a minor complaint about this book, its pacing
was a bit odd at certain places. Otherwise, this book is great. This
book features an unusual protagonist, a good story, while exploring
the philosophical question about the afterlife.
City
of Blades has my recommendation. Check out this series,
starting from the first book,
City of Stairs.